94 Comments

Democrats did this to themselves, and the rest of us. One might say they fucked around and found out, by:

—choosing both Biden and Harris through back room deals

— blocking contested primaries

— smearing leftists who have offered real alternatives

— aligning themselves with Wall Street instead of working class Americans, and

— allowing Netanyahu to disregard international human rights while waging an escalating and expanding genocide across the Middle East.

I posted an expanded version of this comment at https://shahidbuttar.substack.com/p/democrats-did-this-to-themselves.

Democrats essentially aligned themselves with the traditional Republican Party, particularly by treating Liz Cheney as a surrogate, while relying on various acts of theater to project what amounted to a cultural project with little policy substance. https://open.substack.com/pub/shahidbuttar/p/worried-about-tuesday?r=97w99&utm_medium=ios

Beyond Democrats and the fealty to capital that unites them, the community of corporate journalists should also bear a great deal of the blame for Trump’s return to Washington. The rise of propaganda and the loss of trustworthy news media has been a crucial part of the recipe on which Republicans relied. https://shahidbuttar.substack.com/p/journalism-has-fueled-the-rise-of

To the extent people here need a hopeful coda to process what might be a painful moment, I would just applaud everyone here for participating in and supporting the independent media ecosystem. Hedges’ voice is important, as are those of others who share his independence and insight.

Expand full comment

Excellent map Shahid of the corporatized arrogant Democractic Establishment’s evolving long term betrayal of us. Thank you.

Expand full comment
4 hrs ago·edited 4 hrs ago

What about someone like Blinken and Nuland, neocons, and they are now joined at the hip with the democrats.

Expand full comment
4 hrs ago·edited 4 hrs ago

So from reading his post, do you think he, Hedges, would have preferred a Harris win?

Expand full comment

I can't speak for Hedges, but the sad fact is that fascism has been well-entrenched in the U.S. for far long than most Americans seem to think. That's one of the themes I explore in my writing, most recently at https://shahidbuttar.substack.com/p/worried-about-tuesday

Expand full comment

The democrats have been running around calling Trump a fascist which is absurd. Kinzenger wrote an article about Trump's fascism in regard to his telling Tucker Carlson that if nine guns were pointed at Liz Cheney she might have a different view of supporting wars. His whole point was that they are quick to send other people's children to war but protect themselves and their own. To use this as an example of his fascism is to distort the whole meaning of the word and during his administration no doubt many, including the press, will call him a fascist, a Hitler using ridiculous examples to prove their point and rendering the term meaningless.

Expand full comment

Absolutely not.

Expand full comment
founding

I may be naive, but I doubt mass movements and strikes will matter. The two brands of the corporate UniParty corrupt government will simply bail out the corporate oligarchs directly, just like they did in 2008. The citizens are nothing more than items to be fleeced by them now and they will be treated like the Palestinians once they have nothing left to steal from. The USA is a criminal enterprise run by a handful of robber barons.

Expand full comment

The criminal enterprise is collapsing along with the rest of enterprise, however, since the economy is in a state of stagflation that precedes hyperinflation, and once the US dollar is eliminated as the world reserve currency—as it is in the process of being so—it will be only downhill from there. Bailouts will become impossible as the dollar becomes worthless, or will only have the potential to hasten the collapse of the economy and power centres. This has been in the making for a long time.

They have adopted the Zimbabwe strategy of economics, of responding to inflation by printing ever more money; Zimbabwe being the country that became famous for 100 trillion dollar bills that sold more on ebay than they were worth in-country. You needed a suitcase full of money to go buy groceries, or a coffee, and a laminated chart to help figure out how many zeroes make a quintillion or sextillion dollars.

In the collapse, there will be an opportunity for mass movements and the public to seize power. It will become necessary to issue new currency, as the Trump administration apparently already plans to launder the US dollar through digital currencies in foreign countries to try to keep its value up. However, the elites will also form factions as they are already doing, and it is possible one of them could win if we are not organised.

This is also the situation in Europe. Former British diplomat and reporter Alastair Crooke laid out the situation in France quite well with insights from others, and it's comparable:

https://strategic-culture.su/news/2024/07/15/operation-jupiter-and-a-revolution-in-the-making/

“What is in reality a budget and trade deficit is disguised as debt and would have been purged thirty years ago by national currency devaluation – but this debt artifice [increasingly benefits the rich]… whilst the general population never ceases to grumble, living its’ rose-tinted dream – and held in blind ignorance of the state of our finances … That said, the ruling class is well aware of the situation, but prefers not to talk about it, because no one knows what to do."

“There can be no doubt at the moment of truth, when states declare themselves bankrupt … the West will be shaken to the core – and some will pop like champagne corks. The economy will have to be reorganized. Perhaps also we will see cultural revolution. It was the failure of the French State – let us not forget – that provoked the French Revolution …"

"Today, even before the bankruptcy has been declared, the loss of confidence in the institutions: The powerlessness of the public authorities, deprived of prestige and authority, and the detestation of the President – make it possible to foresee the energy of the shockwave that would be unleashed by revelation of the fiasco."

Expand full comment

Without strong unions as a base, there is no mass movement, none.

Expand full comment

Having been a teacher I absolutely agree!

Expand full comment

Mass movements and strikes will matter. But they absolutely must be tied to a clear political party structure making specific material demands. Without that, it is just pussy hats that can be ignored, or workers making themselves a better paid worker in a class hierarchy of workers (affluent unionized workers versus precarious workers).

And obviously we are quite far from such a labor movement. But the future is unknowable. Such movements have existed and accomplished much, they can exist again.

Expand full comment

What? Are the oligarchs chosen by God? Forever?!Pinochet? Just curious. Would you characterize your attitude as defeatist? Had the feminists, gay rights activists and the suffragettes held your attitude about the possible, would each of these populations have experienced any shift in their 2nd, 3rd ,4th class or non entity status that was assigned them in their time? Can you consider Nature’s wisdom in the cost of human birth demands a confrontation with and acceptance of screamingly intense pains called labor. Was your own birth accomplished without pain? Isn’t this a metaphor that can gird us to the seeming impossible?

Expand full comment
founding

My only answer to your response is that we are living in far different times than those you mentioned regarding feminists, gay right activists, and suffragettes, etc. We are actually going backwards from those gains you mentioned now. As one example, millions of people went out into the streets to protest and try to stop the illegal invasion of Iraq under GW Bush, before it happened. It made NO DIFFERENCE. The oligarchs simply no longer care what we want or think. The war happened just as they wanted it to and many many many more wars since then. Another recent example is all the student NON-VIOLENT protestors against the genocide of the Palestinians at college campuses who were met with violence from the government for simply caring about and wanting to stop that violence. The genocide is ongoing full tilt towards Israel’s final solution against the Palestinians with the endless support from the government and corporate monsters. To paraphrase the late great George Carlin: They don’t give a fuck about you or me. They want it all for themselves and they will get it. Are the oligarchs chosen by God? Forever? The reality is that they are in charge and they will not respond to what you or others care about or want. They no longer respond to protestors. They simply brush them off and ignore them. Short of throwing them in jail or worse, and I see no mechanism for doing that, they will continue to operate with impunity. Does that make me a defeatist? Perhaps in some eyes, but I consider myself more of a realist regarding our current situation. Trump being reelected after all he has said and done seems to back my perspective quite well.

Expand full comment
founding

The oligarchs only love money and themselves. What are they going to do when their source of income is not long because their industries are rendered useless due to masive strikes and boicots?

Expand full comment
founding

As I wrote in my original post, I believe they will simply be directly bailed out from the government they own. Just like the big banks were back in 2008. As long as the government is still going, it will simply print more money to give to them. They won’t even need consumers at some point the way things are heading. Eventually the whole system is going to collapse. As far as I am concerned the oligarchs are simply like a cancer which will eventually kill the host and itself. Until then I don’t see strikes having much effect, let alone getting the majority of folks getting behind them. The oligarchs have divided the citizens far too well and I don’t see the citizens overcoming their bigotry and hate that they have been taught to believe in. Not in the USA. We’ll see how it all plays out, but I for one am not optimistic one little bit about where this country is headed towards some unimaginable dystopian nightmare, all because as you pointed out about the oligarchs only loving money and themselves. And for that last point, I don’t even believe they love themselves. I believe they are truly self-loathing monsters who hide behind money to avoid looking at themselves.

Expand full comment
founding

When the oligarchs continue to oppress the people, take away their jobs, and destroy their hopes, what are the brainwashed supporters of the government going to do? I think they will resort to massive strikes and boycotts.

Expand full comment

Spot on as usual. We bear witness to the slow collapse of Empire.

Expand full comment
founding

I would say it is more like a rapid collapse now.

Expand full comment

I believe we're on the precipice of rapid collapse but not there yet. I think the next economic collapse (only a matter of time) will be the "Okay, now this is collapse" moment.

Expand full comment
4 hrs ago·edited 3 hrs ago

Would you be have said this if Harris won?

Expand full comment

Avoid collapse by pushing for more war leading to the end of the human species--if Harris won.

Expand full comment

What I fear most is what is going to happen in the Middle East, in Gaza and the West Bank, and should Trump support that, which is so barbaric, so loathsome, then I will feel we're heading toward the end times. That scenario could bring in Russia and then it will be over. We also need to empower our unions and as a former teacher i can attest to how powerful they can be, and without them how vulnerable you can be, since power in the hands of a few always leads to multiple abuses.

Expand full comment

Team D ran a shit candidate that had never won a seriously contested election in her own name (VP hardly counts) and was chosen last minute by party insiders. Because Harris she had been VP under Biden for four years, she could not pretend that she had no inkling of his obvious senility and could not run on any policy other than the historically unpopular Biden Administration policies.

Had Team D allowed a normal primary process and been able to nominate a candidate not tied at the hip to Biden, they might have done better. If Team D were able to nominate a candidate whose basic qualification was "I was Willie Brown's mistress", they might have done better. And if the queen had balls, she'd be king.

Now, watch democrats and liberals blame everyone and everything, Russia, men, women, minorities, college students, "ungrateful negroes", Lina Khan, Elon Musk, Russia some more, feral tomcats, Peanut The Squirrel, Puertoricans, everyone and everything but themselves for losing to a loudmouth moron reality TV star.

Oh yeah, and Harris outspent Trump 2-1 and had the MSM to act as her unpaid propaganda arm, not to mention most of Big Tech on her side. And She Still Lost.

Expand full comment
5 hrs ago·edited 4 hrs ago

I would prefer Trump won then Harris. We weren't in a proxy war with Russia with the possibility of nuclear war hanging over our heads during the Trump years, and he wasn't assisting a genocide, well, not at the time. I guess once again I will have to watch liberals join hands with the mainstream media in their hatred of Trump and foster lies, like Amy Goodman adopting the lie of Russia-gate. I didn't see the republicans try to remove Biden from office due to his senility, which was obvious from the beginning, which was not true of the democrats during Trump's whole term in office, and strongly supported by our so called liberals. I thought Greenwald was one of the sole liberals who held on to his integrity and didn't hitch his wagon to an anti-Trump hysteria. Also, no new wars under Trump. I wonder what those neocons will do now, since they are now aligned with the democrats and guided their agenda during Biden's presidency?

Expand full comment

May be the more important question - than that about the neocons who will do what they always do because of being incapable of thinking outside their war and hegemony box - is what do you and others of like mind intend to do? In relation to Hedges last handful of paragraphs?

Expand full comment
founding

I think I'm one of the few who won with this election because I voted with my conscience and therefore I voted green and I will not have any regrets. Besides, I'm celebrating that this was the collapse of the democratic party and hope that those who voted for Harris have learned the lesson and will start forming a new party that truely represents the people.

Expand full comment

Team D will not go anywhere, not until the donors get sick of it.

n.b. I also voted Green.

Expand full comment

Chris might as well post the phone number for the National Suicide Hotline at the end of all of his articles.

Expand full comment
7 hrs ago·edited 7 hrs ago

Funny, but I think anyone who reads it that way has misunderstood. Hedges' message is one of the continued spiritual struggle in the face of adversity; one of revolt. It is a positive message. You must know the lay of the land and have a realistic idea of the situation we are in to be able to resist it. I recommend reading "Death of the Liberal Class" by Chris Hedges.

"One of the only coherent philosophical positions is revolt. It is a constant confrontation between man and his obscurity. It is not aspiration, for it is devoid of hope. That revolt is the certainty of a crushing fate, without the resignation that ought to accompany it," writes Albert Camus. "A living man can be enslaved and reduced to the historic condition of an object. But if he dies in refusing to be enslaved, he reaffirms the existence of another kind of human nature which refuses to be classified as an object."

Expand full comment

This.

In my opinion, anybody involved in the Democratic Party political machine who says something along the lines of "It was impossible to win" should retire immediately and let the people who have a positive vision for the future and the will to fight take the reins.

Expand full comment

Emma do you think his response to a Harris win would have been different?. Also one might take away that due to a Trump win all is lost? Don't ask is spot on in how most people would react to this article. Funny too.

Expand full comment

Thanks, Fran. you get it.

Expand full comment

I prefer ugly truth to comofrting lies.

Expand full comment

To the contrary for that would be complicit in the destructive forces he so ably describes. Better, a sign up sheet for determined activism of strategic relentless strikes til the corrupt mess is brought down and the life nurturing systems are conceived and brought into being.

Expand full comment
founding

Anyone who voted for either of the two major parties already committed suicide of their conscience. It's a sad state of affairs.

Expand full comment

Funny and so true!!!!!!!!!! I would have preferred a more down to earth response to Trump winning as opposed to a Harris win. I hope people like Hedges and the left take on a more objective perspective in regard to Trump's presidency, and I don't have to read about the end times like I did during his former presidency.

Expand full comment

This has been the Hedges message for more than two decades. Americans, however, are simply too ignorant of politics, history, and civil life to understand who their real foe is; millions of our fellow citizens are woefully stupid and easily manipulated by demagogues like Trump. We will reap a terrible whirlwind now.

Expand full comment

It is despairing that most the US voted to help Donald Trump to kill Palestinians, so it is very sad day.

Expand full comment

Boy, if only Harris could have said anything or done anything....

Expand full comment

We must learn how to discriminate those worthy for high office from the plebeian. The difference between a Lincoln and a 4 cylinder good deal in the used car park.

Expand full comment

Do you think, especially with the neocons, and Blinken is one of them, the genocide would stop? That Netanyahu would listen had she won? What has she ever done that lends credence to that belief? Not too long ago she was spewing that North Korea is our long time friend. Tell me what she has said or done in the past that gives you such confidence in her?

Expand full comment

You think I have any confidence in Harris?

I suppose sarcasm is sometimes hard to transmit over a acreen.

Expand full comment

Glad to hear it, read it.

Expand full comment

Do you think Hedges would have written this apocalyptic piece had Harris won?

Expand full comment
founding

I appreciate Mr. Hedges's warnings about the dangers of the politicians he profiles. I'm not surprised that he would write about the dangers of these politicians, because he has always warned us about them.

Expand full comment

Don't know. The difference is that Team D now will pretend to rediscover human rights, and the same smug liberals who ladled on the excuses for Biden/Harris will no longer do so for Trump.

Expand full comment

Yes. And requires us to dig deeply to understand the conditions propelling their entry into the cult of Trump, the figurehead for the booming success of the “The Powell Memo (which)has been described (in 1971) as “a call to arms for corporations” and “a corporate blueprint to dominate democracy.” This has been and is a war where one side was spending a lot of attention and money in their corporate coup of our democracy. While the other side played stupefied and uncomprending before Gingrich’s snarling assault on civil relations and Democrats during Reagan’s slap down of workers and the air traffic controllers strike. The Dems rolled over in response until they continued to roll over and over enough to hire a Clinton to demonstrate how they can pretend serving us while slowly signing up for corporate donations to keep them in power. And like Biden serving two masters, one, the money one, not the workers one, won out. Then, they dished up after Biden, Ms Joyful Harris for us to rubber stamp. It is time for sprouting genuine teeth and a flexible yet fierce spine. And channel our fury and grief in the creation of what truly serves life, ours, our children’s, and Earth and her wondrous progeny of the slithering, 2 and 4 and multiple legged, the swimmers , the wingeds and the rooted world.

Expand full comment
4 hrs ago·edited 4 hrs ago

Gee, I thought it was the Biden administration and his Secretary of State, Blinken, a necon, who were assisting in the destruction of Palestine, in Gaza and the West Bank. Did you think it would stop under Harris, and if so what has she said or done to lead you to such a wish filled conclusion?

Expand full comment
5 hrs ago·edited 4 hrs ago

What do you think would happen during her presidency? Do you really believe there would not be a continuation of the genocidal assault on the Palestinians?

Expand full comment

Thank you, Mr. Hedges, once again, for sharing the wisdom you've gained through your studies and your journalism. I am always, if not particularly comforted, at least enlightened by your work. Your ideas are complex, requiring deep listening and rumination. How to convey them to a mass of citizens who want everything described in easy-to-swallow soundbites seems a bit of a challenge, one which I hope some among us are up to. Thank you for your work.

Expand full comment

"We must demand nothing less than full employment, guaranteed minimum incomes, universal health insurance, free education at all levels, robust protection of the natural world and an end to militarism and imperialism. We must create the possibility for a life of dignity, purpose and self-esteem." ... sounds reasonable to me ... I guess "we the people" will say that this is bad for the economy ...

Expand full comment

What's bad for the financialized economy, isn't necessarily bad for the people.

Expand full comment

Who cares what the parasitic oligarchic Fraternity thinks? Other than how we can use it to grow a more nurturant more just society?

Expand full comment

with "they" I didnt mean the oligarchs but the American public ... I will correct that

Expand full comment

Powerful argument well researched. Not sure though that the solution is viable. Like many Americans I have been voting for the “lesser of 2 evils” for most of my life because reason tells me “the greater of 2 evils” is worse, & 3rd parties have been rendered totally impotent & even detrimental in this country. The solution of mass civil disobedience & movements seems very unlikely to be successful in an oligarchic society in which the means of communication & dissemination of informaron are completely controlled by technocratic oligarchs the likes of Elon Musk & Peter Thiel.

Expand full comment

Does anyone know if there are any passing comets I can hop on? Don’t really mind what part of deep space it’s heading.

Expand full comment

An eloquent and thoughtful perspective that deals honestly and accurately with the issues Thank you. 🙏

Expand full comment

Very helpful context, thanks, as always, Chris.

Expand full comment

Well said, Chris. Everyone, please share this widely.

Expand full comment

OMG. Spot on.

Expand full comment

The Trump/Republican victory is a victory for Progressives. The Democrats failed, now Trump will fail, (oligarchy has failed) to save the USA. Now is the time for Progressives to build a viable future for our country. Our enemy is the super wealthy. Who are intellectually, emotionally, dead. The future calls out to us…

Expand full comment